English law prevented dumbledore from being gay in books

Speculation as to how future films in the “Harry Potter” canon would reference (or ignore) Dumbledore’s sexuality has been rampant for more than a decade. Though none of the books provide much insight, Rowling herself revealed that she “ always thought of Dumbledore as gay ” during a appearance at New York’s Carnegie Hall. In a twist that most Harry Potter fans would never have expected, Albus Dumbledore has become the poster child for gay representation in Hollywood, the battlefield being the new Fantastic Beasts film, The Crimes of Grindelwald.

J.K. Rowling confirmed that Dumbledore was canonically gay way back in , but that fact wasn’t actually represented in the books. So we all held hope that the.

Is dumbledore gay for grindelwald

Unlike the previous "Fantastic Beasts" films, young Dumbledore (Jude Law) talks directly, albeit briefly in moments that feel awkwardly inserted, about being in love with Grindelwald "with lines. October Rowling reveals Dumbledore is gay The author appeared at Carnegie Hall in to answer fan questions after the publication of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.

Jude Law Defends Decision to Not Make Young Dumbledore 'Explicitly' Gay in 'Fantastic Beasts 2' In January, the film's director David Yates told Entertainment Weekly that Dumbledore, whom Rowling. Now, the powerful wizards are the only ones capable of stopping the other, a fact that pushes Dumbledore in all the wrong places.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - the consequence of dumbledore being gay Showing of

If you don't like someone because of their sexuality perference, that doesn't mean that you can harrassed them or talk shit about them. If people read it there, great, if not, the book is still their own to enjoy. I never knew that! My point is, it isn't relevant to the series, or the overall story being told. More on this story. Lauren wrote: "Noooo Dumbledore was "horribly, terribly let down" she said, and his love for Grindelwald was his "great tragedy".

But simply being told that he was gay doesn't impact the story or what I think of the character, it is pretty inconsequential. Jun 12, PM. Took the words right out of my mouth, and then some. Rather or not Dumbledore is gay or straight, has nothing to do with the man he was. Yes, I know Rowling said it, but I reject it.

I always hoped that in last part he would marry McGonnagall and live as long as Nicholas Flamel does, but.. Related internet links. Levi wrote: "he was in love with snape" He was in love with grindewald sp? In the end, Dumbledore is still a great Wizard, headmaster, and mentor to Harry, no matter what his sexual orientation or preference.

Dumbledore is homosexual. When neither's sexual orientation has consequences, we'll probably be doing better as a species. A what if he's gay? Share this —. She left a homosexual relationship entirely in subtext of her first one and only confirmed it in a much later and not originally planned installment. Dumbledore's sexual preference was no part of that. Gretchen wrote: " It would be like Rowling coming out to say "by the way McGonogall was straight.

This is a discussion, no one is throwing haterade around, no one is bashing, it's just one person asking others their opinions. As JulieLaLa said above, it has no bearing on the story so shouldn't affect your own percception of the story. Jace wrote: "sorry, but how did u guys not know that???